NOVASMC

GAME DECISION MAP

Clash of Clans

Base-building Strategy · Mobile · 2012

Current analysisBaseline 2026-06-21Open Decision Analysis →

Build and upgrade the Home Village → train troops and configure an army → raid players or AI for Gold, Elixir, and Dark Elixir → reinvest resources into Town Hall, buildings, research, Heroes, and Equipment → join Clan Wars, CWL, Clan Capital, and Clan Games → return to the Home Village and attack again.

Recurring Structures

Detailed Repeating Structures

What repeats and keeps the system moving?

CORE CLASSIFICATION

Compounding Growth

Build and upgrade the Home Village → train troops and configure an army → raid players or AI for Gold, Elixir, and Dark Elixir → reinvest resources into Town Hall, buildings, research, Heroes, and Equipment → join Clan Wars, CWL, Clan Capital, and Clan Games → return to the Home Village and attack again.

Outputs strengthen assets, capabilities, or access and open a stronger next cycle.

View pattern definition →
  1. Core

    Home Village Core Loop

    Base design → army composition → attack → defense outcome → reinvestment remains the hub that all spokelike modes feed.

  2. Economy

    Growth-to-Economy Loop

    growth contents supply Gold/Elixir/Dark Elixir/Ore/Medals, which consumes through upgrades and controls through sinks.

  3. Competition

    Competition Validation Loop

    turns account power into trophies, stars, destruction, medals, rank and clan status.

  4. Cooperation

    Clan

    ties donations, Clan Games, Clan Capital, Raid Weekend and chat/recruitment to the same core account progress.

  5. Return

    Event Recontextualization Loop

    events do not replace the core loop; they reinterpret attacks, clan tasks and season goals with new rewards.

  6. Return

    Hero Journey Catch-up Loop

    Permanent Hero Hall track converts accumulated Hero Levels into equipment, Ore, skin and catch-up value.

  7. Supply

    Gold Pass

    Monthly Daily Tasks, Stamp Cards, Choice Nodes and season rewards thicken the reward layer over the core loop.

  8. Economy

    Event Shop

    Limited event currencies route event actions to Epic Equipment, Ore, Magic Items and cosmetics via Trader/Event tab.

  9. Cooperation

    Global Chat Recruitment Loop

    Groups, Communities and Town Square reconnect public discovery, recruitment and clan settlement to the core loop.

Bottlenecks

Bottleneck Patterns

Where do decisions and flow break?

CORE CLASSIFICATION

Resource and Value Conversion Failure

The affected flow runs through Ore → Builder; its limiting point is the combat growth reinvestment handoff.

Currencies, assets, products, or inputs do not convert reliably into utility or residual value.

View pattern definition →
  1. Core

    Resource and Value Conversion Failure · Combat Growth

    The affected flow runs through Ore → Builder; its limiting point is the combat growth reinvestment handoff.

  2. Supporting

    Outcome and Contribution Attribution Failure · Cooperation

    The limiting point sits in the cooperation result handoff.

  3. Supporting

    Fairness and Legitimacy Erosion · Competition

    The affected flow runs through Ranked/War → replay → loadout; its limiting point is the competition result handoff.

  4. Supporting

    Decision and Planning Calculability Breakdown · Economy Growth

    The affected flow runs through Hero Equipment; its limiting point is the economy growth planning handoff.

  5. Supporting

    Obligation and Volition Erosion · Liveops Event

    The limiting point sits in the liveops event return handoff.

  6. Supporting

    Rights and Lifecycle Discontinuity · Commerce Entitlement

    The affected flow runs through transaction → entitlement → post-use; its limiting point is the commerce entitlement settlement handoff.

Contradictions

Contradiction Patterns

What must improve, and what must remain protected?

CORE CLASSIFICATION

Action and Return Continuity vs System Depth and Throughput

Improve Performance Vs Load while preserving Complexity Vs Convenience.

Continuity to the next action, return, or reinvestment must improve while route diversity, strategic depth, and throughput remain protected.

View pattern definition →
  1. Core

    Core Contradiction

    Improve Performance Vs Load while preserving Complexity Vs Convenience.

  2. Supporting

    Independent Social Propagation

    Improve Complexity Vs Convenience while preserving Performance Vs Load.

  3. Supporting

    Independent Competition Contract

    Improve Freedom Vs Control while preserving None.

  4. Supporting

    Core Economic Transfer Face

    Across source/sink, improve Freedom Vs Control while preserving Revenue Vs Trust.

  5. Supporting

    Independent Temporal

    Improve Complexity Vs Convenience while preserving Stability Vs Volatility.

  6. Supporting

    Independent Commerce

    Across entitlement, improve Complexity Vs Convenience while preserving Revenue Vs Trust.

Solution Mechanisms

Solution Mechanisms

Which intervention mechanism changes the condition?

CORE CLASSIFICATION

Route and Return Handoff

Apply Route and Return Handoff across Reward-to-Next-Action Router while preserving the protected value.

Connect the current state to valid next actions, routes, retries, and returns while preserving choice and existing paths.

View pattern definition →
  1. Core

    Reward-to-Next-Action Router

    Apply Route and Return Handoff across Reward-to-Next-Action Router while preserving the protected value.

  2. Supporting

    Contribution-to-Completion Closure Card

    Apply State and Rule Visibility Encoding across Contribution-to-Completion Closure Card while preserving the protected value.

  3. Supporting

    Rule–Result–Replay Closure

    Apply State and Rule Visibility Encoding across Rule Result Replay Closure while preserving the protected value.

  4. Supporting

    Currency Role & Policy Contract Card

    Apply State and Rule Visibility Encoding across Currency Role & Policy Contract Card while preserving the protected value.

  5. Supporting

    Purpose–Window–Choice Closure Card

    Apply State and Rule Visibility Encoding across Purpose Window Choice Closure Card while preserving the protected value.

  6. Supporting

    One-Contract Compare–Commit–Receipt Closure

    Apply Loss Trust and Entitlement Buffer across One-Contract Compare Commit Receipt Closure while preserving the protected value.

Solution Compositions

Solution Compositions

How should interventions be combined and sequenced?

CORE CLASSIFICATION

Single-Track Localized Bundle

Connect 1 source-declared mechanism across Reward-to-Next-Action Router as Single-Track Localized Bundle.

Combine a core intervention with stabilizing or accelerating support within one problem track and keep its impact localized.

View pattern definition →
  1. Core

    Reward-to-Next-Action Router Composition

    Connect 1 source-declared mechanism across Reward-to-Next-Action Router as Single-Track Localized Bundle.

  2. Supporting

    Contribution-to-Completion Closure Card Composition

    Connect 1 source-declared mechanism across Contribution-to-Completion Closure Card as Single-Track Localized Bundle.

  3. Supporting

    Rule–Result–Replay Closure Composition

    Connect 1 source-declared mechanism across Rule Result Replay Closure as Single-Track Localized Bundle.

  4. Supporting

    Currency Role & Policy Contract Card Composition

    Connect 1 source-declared mechanism across Currency Role & Policy Contract Card as Single-Track Localized Bundle.

  5. Supporting

    Purpose–Window–Choice Closure Card Composition

    Connect 1 source-declared mechanism across Purpose Window Choice Closure Card as Single-Track Localized Bundle.

  6. Supporting

    One-Contract Compare–Commit–Receipt Closure Composition

    Connect 1 source-declared mechanism across One-Contract Compare Commit Receipt Closure as Single-Track Localized Bundle.

  7. Supporting

    Parallel Solution-Mechanism Composition

    Connect 6 source-declared mechanisms across Reward-to-Next-Action Router as Core-First Branch-Sequential Portfolio.

  8. Supporting

    Parallel Solution-Mechanism Composition

    Connect 6 source-declared mechanisms across Reward-to-Next-Action Router as Parallel Local Contracts with Independent Rollback.